21 Old-Fashioned Desserts From the Church Cookbook Era That Deserve a Comeback This Holiday Season

Photo of author

| Published:

Old-fashioned desserts tend to rely on pantry basics like brown sugar, corn syrup, evaporated milk, and butter, which makes them a good fit for a busy holiday season. This set brings back a few classics, from a press-in-crust pecan pie and stovetop fudge to applesauce cake, a lemony angel pie, and frog eye salad. Several can be made a day or more ahead, so they fit around the rest of the holiday baking.

Chocolate Pecan Pie Bars

A stack of three pecan pie bars on a white plate.
Chocolate Pecan Pie Bars. Photo credit: Easy Homemade Life.

Pecan pie and chocolate meet in these bars, which come out of the oven with a slight wobble in the center and firm up as they chill. A buttery shortbread crust holds a corn syrup and brown sugar filling with pecans and little chocolate chips. They keep in the fridge for two to three days and slice neatly when cold.
Get the Recipe: Chocolate Pecan Pie Bars

Old Fashioned Fudge

A hand holding a piece of chocolate fudge with visible walnut pieces; more fudge and chocolate chips are blurred in the background.
Old Fashioned Fudge. Photo credit: Easy Homemade Life.

This is the kind of fudge that once came out of a heavy saucepan every holiday season, made with chocolate chips, butter, marshmallows, evaporated milk, sugar, and walnuts. It boils for exactly five minutes with constant stirring, then chills into 48 pieces. Brushing sugar crystals off the sides of the pot keeps it smooth instead of grainy.
Get the Recipe: Old Fashioned Fudge

Apple Cinnamon Cake

A slice of moist apple cinnamon cake is lifted from a whole cake.
Apple Cinnamon Cake. Photo credit: Easy Homemade Life.

Tender, buttery cake studded with diced apple sits under a cinnamon-sugar topping and a powdered sugar glaze. It bakes in an 8-inch pan in about 30 minutes. Mix only until combined so the crumb stays soft, and wait until the cake cools completely before glazing. Leftovers last two days on the counter or longer chilled.
Get the Recipe: Apple Cinnamon Cake

Pecan Pie

A slice of pecan pie sits on a white plate, with more pie slices and a pie dish in the background on a white table.
Pecan Pie. Photo credit: Easy Homemade Life.

Every bit of crust for this pecan pie gets pressed into the pan with oil and milk, so there is no dough to roll. Corn syrup, eggs, sugar, and melted butter make the filling, with a generous layer of pecans on top. Stir the filling only until combined, because extra air can crack the top as it bakes.
Get the Recipe: Pecan Pie

Pumpkin Dump Cake

A slice of pumpkin dump cake topped with whipped cream and nuts on a white plate, with a spoon resting beside it.
Pumpkin Dump Cake. Photo credit: Quick Prep Recipes.

Baked a few days early, this dump cake holds up to four days in the fridge, which frees up a busy week. Pumpkin puree, evaporated milk, eggs, and brown sugar go into a 9×13 dish under a layer of yellow cake mix, butter, and pecans. Evaporated milk and sweetened condensed milk are not interchangeable here, so grab the right can.
Get the Recipe: Pumpkin Dump Cake

Angel Pie

A piece of lemon dessert with a creamy white layer and crumbly crust on a plate, with a fork holding a bite and a lemon in the background.
Angel Pie. Photo credit: Easy Homemade Life.

Instead of pastry, this pie sits on a baked meringue made from egg whites, cream of tartar, and sugar. A lemon filling made from the yolks and fresh lemon juice gets layered with whipped cream, then the whole pie chills. Adding the sugar one tablespoon at a time keeps the meringue glossy and stable, so the crust holds its shape.
Get the Recipe: Angel Pie

Applesauce Cake

A slice of frosted applesauce cake with nuts on a white scalloped plate, accompanied by a fork.
Applesauce Cake. Photo credit: Easy Homemade Life.

Unsweetened applesauce, walnuts, raisins, and warm spices make this a moist, old-fashioned snack cake, finished with whipped cream cheese frosting. It bakes in a 9×13 dish in about 30 minutes and stays moist for up to three days in an airtight container. Chill the frosting for 15 minutes if it seems too soft to spread.
Get the Recipe: Applesauce Cake

3 Ingredient Peanut Butter Blossoms

A plate of peanut butter blossoms, with one cookie broken in half.
3 Ingredient Peanut Butter Blossoms. Photo credit: Quick Prep Recipes.

Soft, chewy peanut butter cookies topped with chocolate Hershey’s Kisses bring a nostalgic touch to the holiday dessert table. The simple dough comes together with peanut butter, sugar, and an egg, making it an easy treat without a long ingredient list. Pressing the chocolate kisses into the dough before baking helps keep the cookies from cracking as they bake.
Get the Recipe: 3 Ingredient Peanut Butter Blossoms

Frog Eye Salad

A bowl of creamy frog eye salad sits on a table next to a stripe cloth napkin and spoons.
Frog Eye Salad. Photo credit: Easy Homemade Life.

Frog eye salad can turn watery when the fruit isn’t drained well, which thins out the custard and whipped topping. Tiny acini di pepe pasta, a sweet egg custard, pineapple, mandarin oranges, red grapes, and Cool Whip come together after four hours in the fridge. Fold rather than stir to keep the fruit whole and the topping light.
Get the Recipe: Frog Eye Salad

Red Velvet Cake

A ring-shaped red velvet cake with white icing is sliced to reveal its red interior, displayed on a pink cake stand.
Red Velvet Cake. Photo credit: Easy Homemade Life.

Red velvet cake fits right in on a December dessert spread, with its deep red crumb and tangy cream cheese frosting. This version bakes in a bundt pan with buttermilk, oil, and a little cocoa, so there are no layers to stack. Bringing the cream cheese, eggs, and dairy to room temperature keeps both the batter and the frosting smooth.
Get the Recipe: Red Velvet Cake

Chocolate Fudge Cake

A slice of chocolate fudge cake with glossy frosting on a white plate.
Chocolate Fudge Cake. Photo credit: Easy Homemade Life.

Pouring hot coffee into the batter wakes up the cocoa in this rich fudge cake, without leaving any coffee flavor behind. A scoop of sour cream gives the crumb its moist bite, while a double boiler melts semi-sweet chips into heavy cream for a ganache that chills about an hour. Gentle stirring matters here, because an overworked batter bakes up dense.
Get the Recipe: Chocolate Fudge Cake

Peach Cobbler Made with Cake Mix Recipe

A plate of peach cobbler topped with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.
Peach Cobbler Made with Cake Mix Recipe. Photo credit: Easy Homemade Life.

Sliced peaches in heavy syrup, half a cup of melted butter, and a single 15.25-ounce box of cake mix are everything this shortcut cobbler asks for. Those three layers go into an 8×8 dish unstirred and bake 40 to 45 minutes until golden and bubbling. Saving back part of the syrup gives a sturdier, cake-like top, while adding every drop keeps the fruit saucy.
Get the Recipe: Peach Cobbler Made with Cake Mix Recipe

Lemon Blueberry Pound Cake

Lemon blueberry pound cake with glaze on a wooden board, partially sliced.
Lemon Blueberry Pound Cake. Photo credit: Easy Homemade Life.

Sunken blueberries are a common pound cake letdown, and a light dusting of flour on the damp berries is what fixes it here. Bright lemon juice and grated peel flavor the soft, buttery batter, which bakes slowly for close to an hour. After the loaf cools all the way, a sweet lemon glaze drips over the top for a pretty holiday dessert plate.
Get the Recipe: Lemon Blueberry Pound Cake

Berry Dump Cake

A serving of vanilla ice cream topped with blueberry crumble dessert on a white plate.
Berry Dump Cake. Photo credit: Easy Homemade Life.

Jammy, bubbling berries sit under a crisp, buttery cake layer in this dump cake, and no mixing bowl is required. Fresh or frozen fruit gets a sprinkle of sugar and a squeeze of lemon right in a 10-inch skillet, then disappears under dry mix and butter. A second drizzle over any pale patches helps the top bake deep golden instead of powdery.
Get the Recipe: Berry Dump Cake

Peanut Butter Brownies from Mix

Six chocolate brownies with caramel swirls on parchment paper.
Peanut Butter Brownies from Mix. Photo credit: Easy Homemade Life.

Rich chocolate and creamy peanut butter swirl together in these brownies, which begin with a boxed mix and just a few additions from the fridge. Dollops of peanut butter get dragged through the batter with a butter knife before 15 to 18 minutes of baking. Jif or Skippy ripples more smoothly than natural peanut butter, which tends to separate in the heat.
Get the Recipe: Peanut Butter Brownies from Mix

Magic Cookies

Magic cookies cooling on a black wire rack over a marble surface.
Magic Cookies. Photo credit: Easy Homemade Life.

Not a speck of flour goes into these magic cookies. Rich egg yolks bind shredded coconut, walnuts, and chocolate chips with a little sugar and butter, and the dough firms up during a half-hour chill so it scoops cleanly. Baking stops after 8 to 10 minutes, once the edges turn golden-brown, and a sealed tin holds them for up to five days.
Get the Recipe: Magic Cookies

3 Ingredient Shortbread

A close-up of several rectangular pieces of shortbread placed on a wooden surface.
3 Ingredient Shortbread. Photo credit: Quick Prep Recipes.

Cookie trays at the holidays get a simple, buttery addition with this shortbread, built on nothing more than three pantry staples. The dough presses into a glass baking dish and bakes low, then gets sliced and pricked while still warm before going back in briefly. Slicing it warm gives cleaner edges than waiting until the pan has cooled on the counter.
Get the Recipe: 3 Ingredient Shortbread

Almond Crescent Cookies

A plate of almond crescent cookies is being dusted with powdered sugar.
Almond Crescent Cookies. Photo credit: Quick Prep Recipes.

Almond shows up twice in these crescent cookies, once as almond flour and again as almond extract. Softened butter is the key to a tender dough, since cold butter makes it hard and crumbly, and stirring by hand stops the cookies from turning dry. They need no chilling, bake in about 15 minutes, and get a generous coat of powdered sugar afterward.
Get the Recipe: Almond Crescent Cookies

Popcorn Balls

A popcorn ball mixed with red and green m&m's and sprinkles sits on a white pedestal, with festive decorations in the background.
Popcorn Balls. Photo credit: Easy Homemade Life.

Throwback holiday treats don’t get much simpler than popcorn balls, held together with a sugar and corn syrup coating cooked to 270°F on a candy thermometer. Warm popcorn waits in a low oven while the syrup boils, and shaping has to happen fast because it firms quickly. A light touch keeps each ball chewy rather than dense, and wrapped ones stay fresh for days.
Get the Recipe: Popcorn Balls

No Crust Cheesecake

A slice of cheesecake topped with a layer of red strawberry sauce on a white plate.
No Crust Cheesecake. Photo credit: Easy Homemade Life.

Chilled overnight, this cheesecake skips the crust entirely and bakes right in a 9-inch pie pan. Half an hour on the counter for the cream cheese and eggs keeps the batter lump-free, and a tangy sour cream layer bakes on for a last 15 minutes. It keeps up to five days in the fridge, so it can be finished well ahead of the holiday crowd.
Get the Recipe: No Crust Cheesecake

Butterscotch Brownies

Three butterscotch brownies on parchment paper with shredded coconut scattered nearby on a dark surface.
Butterscotch Brownies. Photo credit: Easy Homemade Life.

Twenty-five minutes in the oven turns brown sugar, butter, coconut, and walnuts into chewy butterscotch bars. The butter and sugar melt together on the stove first and need to cool before the eggs go in, or the eggs can scramble. Let the pan cool completely before cutting for clean, neat squares that hold together in a cookie tin.
Get the Recipe: Butterscotch Brownies

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.