A lawyer began canning cranberries over a century ago, and families still argue about it

Photo of author

| Updated:

Cranberry sauce shows up on the table in two main ways. One is a pot of berries cooked with sugar and water, sometimes with a few other add-ins, then chilled until thick. The other is canned jellied sauce, which holds the shape of its can. The debate rages on: canned or fresh. Which version of cranberry sauce deserves a spot on your Thanksgiving table?

A wicker basket filled with fresh cranberries outdoors, set against a background of fallen autumn leaves.
Photo credit: YayImages.

Canned cranberry sauce should be sliced into half-inch rounds, after a rubber spatula is run between the edge of the can and the sauce to break the air seal. A whole-berry version also comes in a can, so your choice at the store isn’t limited to jellied or fresh. But making it from scratch is quite simple, and most bags of cranberries come with a recipe. Fresh berries, water and sugar. Boil, then chill. That’s it.

Bagged fresh berries make up a small share of the cranberry crop. A federal estimate expects about 96% of the crop to be processed and about 301,000 barrels to reach the fresh market, based on recent-year averages. A Wisconsin growers group, speaking for the state that grows more than 60% of the nation’s cranberries, puts the state’s fresh share at about 5% and says the rest goes into juices, dried cranberries, sauces and other products. Neither figure breaks out how much of the processed share becomes sauce.

Americans split on canned and scratch sauce

24% of adults celebrating Thanksgiving said they prefer canned cranberry sauce and 22% said they prefer sauce made from scratch. The pollsters described the result as a lack of consensus. Cranberry sauce also topped the list of most disliked parts of the holiday, named by 18% of celebrants, while 2% called it their favorite.

Fresh berries have a short season

Cranberries are harvested in autumn and are widely available fresh from October to December. Robert Cox, coauthor of a history of Massachusetts cranberry growing, told Smithsonian Magazine that picking runs about six weeks, and that before canning the berries had to be eaten right away, with almost no market the rest of the year.

Homemade takes about 20 minutes

Ocean Spray publishes a recipe for homemade sauce that calls for a 12-ounce bag of fresh or frozen cranberries plus a cup each of sugar and water. The sugar and water boil first, then the berries go in for about 10 minutes of gentle simmering. The recipe lists five minutes of prep and 15 of cooking, and it yields about 2 1/4 cups. Let the sauce cool at room temperature, then chill in the refrigerator until serving. Cooking time sets the texture: berries simmered longer release more of their natural pectin, and the longest-cooked sauce is the firmest and holds its shape once cooled. Penn State Extension says a top-quality fresh berry usually keeps in the refrigerator for up to a month.

A pair of hands holding a large handful of ripe red berries, with more berries scattered in the background, capturing the abundance and vibrant spirit of fall harvest festivals.
Photo credit: Depositphotos.

Easy ways to dress up either version

Canned sauce takes to add-ins with little effort. Food Network’s Sunny Anderson mixes jellied and whole berry sauce and brightens it with orange juice and zest, which she says makes it feel “like it’s your own.” Other cooks stir orange zest and a tablespoon of orange liqueur into whole berry sauce and make it up to two days ahead, with chopped toasted pecans as an option. Homemade sauce has more room for flavor, since the add-ins simmer in the pot. Options include a cinnamon stick, star anise, cardamom pods, a rosemary sprig, vanilla extract and honey. Orange is the common thread in both versions, and these cranberry recipes offer more ideas.

What the can offers

Ocean Spray, a cooperative of about 700 farmers, says its jellied sauce is made with the same 100% North American cranberries as its Cranberry Juice Cocktail, with no artificial flavors or preservatives. The ingredients are cranberries, high fructose corn syrup, corn syrup and water. Marcus Urann, a lawyer who owned cranberry bogs, began selling canned cranberry sauce in 1912. The jellied version reached shelves nationwide in 1941.

How long each version keeps

Ocean Spray’s FAQ says an unopened can can be stored at room temperature or in the refrigerator, and an opened one can be kept up to two weeks in the refrigerator once the sauce is out of the can and tightly covered. Sauce made at home keeps up to one week in an airtight container, the FAQ says. The company does not recommend freezing cranberry sauce, which it says may turn too watery after thawing.

Mandy writes about food, home and the kind of everyday life that feels anything but ordinary. She has traveled extensively, and those experiences have shaped everything, from comforting meals to small lifestyle upgrades that make a big difference. You’ll find all her favorite recipes over at Hungry Cooks Kitchen.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.