Plenty of turkeys go home with a box of stuffing in the same grocery order, and some cooks are still deciding between that box and the family recipe. Either route can end in a dish that soaks up gravy and fills a next-day sandwich. National Stuffing Day on Nov. 21 gives you time to decide what goes into the dish before Thanksgiving.

Boxed stuffing is a tradition in its own right, and family recipes have their own loyalists. Some home cooks are devoted to sage, others to pecans. The base is the same either way: bread soaked in broth and flavored with onion and sage. Cooked inside the turkey, it is stuffing, and baked in its own pan, it is dressing. Either way, you get plenty of flavor and the perfect dish to smother with gravy.
Instacart order data shows the box riding along with the turkey
Instacart order data puts boxed stuffing in about 1 in 4 turkey orders: it appeared in 25.0% of fresh whole-turkey orders at 55 times the typical rate, and 26.2% of frozen ones, while gravy showed up in about 1 in 8 turkey orders. The box works because it cuts prep work and the number of ingredients to buy, and the bread comes seasoned and dried. A from-scratch version can stay simple too, with cubed bread, onion, sage and broth. On Instacart, boxed stuffing made Thanksgiving week’s list of biggest risers, jumping 897%, and sage rose 1,116%. Orders with a fresh whole turkey were also 79 times as likely to include dried sage.
Upgrades such as sausage, mushrooms, apple and extra broth work on either version, and toasting the bread cubes helps a from-scratch batch hold its shape. Tastes Delicious, a catalog of recipes from real food bloggers, is another place to look for stuffing ideas.
At the table, stuffing soaks up gravy and balances the plate
Stuffing soaks up gravy and pan juices. Dressing bakes in its own pan, so the top turns crisp while the center stays soft, and a spoonful of cranberry sauce on the side balances the richness. Canned cranberries turned up in 16.3% of fresh-turkey orders and 18.5% of frozen-turkey orders, beating fresh cranberries by more than 2 to 1.
Bread choice decides the texture. Drier, sturdier cubes hold more broth, so toasted or oven-dried cubes beat bread that only sat out overnight. A tight crumb holds up better than an open one, which means a close-grained loaf keeps its shape under a full dose of broth. Add broth gradually, a little at a time, until the cubes are moist but not swimming. Resting the mixture before baking gives the bread time to soak up the broth.
Family recipes shape the pan, boxed or not
Where a family comes from often shows up in what goes into the bird or the pan. Cornbread dressing is linked to Southern cooking, while other households use white bread or sourdough with sausage or oysters, and the name changes by family. The stuffing-or-dressing debate shows how oysters, cornbread, wild rice and chestnuts show up in different regions. Oyster dressing runs from New England down the East Coast to the Lowcountry, and one South Carolina recipe starts with crumbled day-old cornbread mixed with celery and onion sauteed in butter.
A box can taste like the family recipe with a few additions. Crumbled cornbread stirred into the mix gives it Southern flavor. Browned sausage with cooked onion and celery adds a savory base, and broth in place of some of the water deepens the flavor.
Leftover stuffing keeps for up to four days in the refrigerator
Federal food safety guidance for Thanksgiving leftovers says to refrigerate them within two hours and treats refrigerated leftovers as safe for up to four days. USDA also says to reheat leftovers to 165 degrees Fahrenheit and to divide large portions into smaller containers for quicker cooling. USDA recommends cooking stuffing separately from the turkey for uniform doneness, which is how dressing is made, and stuffing that does cook inside the bird needs its center to reach 165 degrees too. Leftovers that are not finished within four days can go in the freezer for longer storage.
Leftover stuffing stays moist with a splash of broth and a cover over the dish while it reheats. A scoop makes a filling for a next-day sandwich, and a hot skillet crisps it beside a fried egg. Mixed with leftover turkey and mashed potatoes, stuffing also fries up as stuffing and turkey patties. Toasted bread cubes and leftover turkey also bake into a leftover Thanksgiving casserole with a stuffing-style base. Halved squash or peppers also hold stuffing for a baked second meal.
National Stuffing Day honors the dish, whatever it is called
Good stuffing comes down to what a cook is willing to make. A box and a handed-down recipe can both get there. The choice matters less than the care put into the bread and the seasoning. A pan that people go back to for seconds is the best sign the cook chose well.
Jennifer Allen is a retired professional chef and long-time writer. Her work appears in dozens of publications, including MSN, Yahoo, The Washington Post and The Seattle Times. These days, she’s busy in the kitchen developing recipes and traveling the world, and you can find all her best creations at Cook What You Love.